4.5/5
Lincoln the man, the politician,
the professor, the father, the martyr, and the myth: director Steven Spielberg’s
extraordinary new biopic (based on the book Team
of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln by Doris Kearns Goodwin)
reveals the many layers of its subject with the grace and solemnity of a
battlefield hymn. With cinematic
shape-shifter Daniel Day-Lewis in the lead role, Lincoln is the most
powerful and profound and deeply moving Hollywood dramatization of the American
icon’s life since 1939—when Henry Fonda donned the famous hat and beard in John
Ford’s peerless classic Young Mr. Lincoln.
From War Horse’s sumptuous green valleys to Lincoln’s traditionally high-contrast interiors, it’s evident that
Spielberg yearns to echo the majesty of that late cinematic deity. But where Ford began Lincoln’s journey,
depicting his humble origins as an Illinois litigator, Spielberg finishes it. By early 1865—the waning days of the
Civil War—that promising youth had grown into a weary elder statesman. If his presidency and life were
fatefully truncated by a gunshot at Ford’s Theater, Spielberg’s film reminds us
that his legacy lives in his immortal doctrines and words.
The film begins with a
fierce skirmish in the pouring rain and mud. But the war on the battlefield is basically over (spoiler:
The South lose). A new conflict is
brewing in the halls of Congress, wherein Lincoln seeks to ratify the 13th
Amendment, thereby lawfully and constitutionally abolishing slavery. Dissension among rival partisans and a potential
Southern peace negotiation combine to complicate the procedure of ratification. Lincoln’s stressed-out Secretary of
State, William Seward (David Strathairn), is tasked with procuring the twenty
congressional votes needed to reach a two-thirds consensus. Assisted by three colorful lobbyists
(James Spader, John Hawkes, and Tim Blake Nelson), (dis)honest Abe exercises
the chicanery intrinsic in democratic politics, suggesting that lawmaking is
essentially a game of wheeling and dealing.
The film depicts a
veritable hen House of Representatives, where squabbling debaters hurl insults
about in eloquent 19th century vernacular. Occasionally, I worried the movie would wallow excessively
in the legislature, but the complex domesticity of the White House aptly
dispensed those concerns. As the
screwy Mary Lincoln (Molly to her beloved), Sally Field plays inexorable
emotionality to Abe’s modest stoicism.
As her husband is too mandatorily stolid to express the sorrow he feels
for the thousands of sons lost during his administration, Mary is the more
outwardly bereaved that their own son Willie died three years earlier. It’s been speculated that Mary suffered
from bipolar disorder, and her ailment is visualized emphatically in a single
jarring edit; her inconsolable sadness is wiped away by a demented grin.
The nearly wordless
rapport between Abe and his youngest son, Tad (Gulliver McGrath), is perhaps
the most affecting; it attests to
the paternalism discernable in the President’s overall nature, towards his
family, of course, but his people as well. One particularly striking tableau sits Lincoln in an Oval Office rocking chair with Tad on his
lap. Like a baroque painting, father
and child cuddle over a picture book as lustrous sunbeams from the window
pierce the blackness and illuminate their intimacy. It’s an image worthy of art galleries and recalls the famous
statue that stands in Richmond, Virginia to this day. Lincoln’s discordant relationship with his oldest son,
Robert (Joseph Gordon-Levitt), a would-be Yankee soldier, feels shoehorned and
melodramatic in comparison.
Nevertheless, Day-Lewis
gives a career-highlight performance. His eyes sunken, his shoulders heavy, his steps short, his
voice high and courtly, the two-time Oscar winner channels the real man as best
as historical records describe. But
showing his figure in wistful silhouette from behind, Lincoln also memorializes a symbol, a mythic insignia of a struggle
that still remains largely unfinished.
In addition, Spielberg and Day-Lewis make the President a raconteur: he doesn’t really talk; he
orates. His incipient thoughts
seem to roll around his head like musket balls before flowing forth elegantly. Besides one hilariously aggravated
cabinet member, who’s had enough of Abe’s speechifying, the whole world takes
pause to listen. Day-Lewis’
performance speaks to Lincoln’s wisdom, melancholy, sense of humor, and larger
than life aura.
Actually, the whole stock
of characters is fantastic. Boardwalk Empire’s Michael Stuhlberg has
a significant role as an ambivalent congressman trembling before his cohorts. Speaking for the South in a tense but
mannered confrontation between belligerents (a more civilized assemblage than
wartime Congress, I must say), Confederate Vice President Alexander Stephens
(Jackie Earle Haley) imparts succinctly and stately the Southern cause: not
racism, not enslavement, but preserving a way of life, a culture (few Confederate
soldiers actually owned slaves).
Lincoln’s strongest ally in the House is club-footed abolitionist Thaddeus
Stevens (Tommy Lee Jones), whose principled aggression is public from the podium,
but the extent of whose dedication is only revealed to us behind closed doors.
Beautifully shot by Janusz Kamiński in nuanced close-ups and vivid period imagery, underlined by John Williams’ courageous marching-song score (reminiscent of Saving Private Ryan) and Tony Kushner’s dialogue cribbed in spirit from Civil War letters and diaries, Lincoln is a great film. Although Spielberg’s movies are often so maudlin they appear filmed through a pane of sugar glass, his latest is an epic achievement that’s vastly expressive through images while celebrating the might and endurance of the spoken word as well. It was said of the President on his deathbed, “Now he belongs to the ages.” Though he’s long been quiet, Lincoln insinuates that somehow he teaches us still.